prettiest boy
Sunday April 25, 2004 11:06pm
beings that i am secretly insecure about my writing abilities, hell, abilities in general (and by saying that you understand that it translates to being completely obsessed with myself and who might be observing me), i occasionally go back and read reviews that i have written on this website looking for comments that people may or may not have written about them. i haven't written for the website in a while partly because i have been dealing with my own shit and partly because the last review i wrote was completely deconstructed and made fun of by some anonymous guy. which is reason #1 why i will never be a critic, or any sort of a writer, ever: i care too much about what people think of me. but this is not the reason i am all up in arms right now. someone had the following to say about a review that i wrote of seven's travels by atmosphere, back in january:
"It's so sad that this piece relies so heavily on the Eminem comparison when Slug is not even "white". But who cares? If your understanding of hip hop pivots on race or geography shut up."
here is a link to the original review.
basically, this is my rebuttal to this person because i don't have the guts to do it in the original forum.
people can say whatever they want. i am not denying this. and i suppose it's my fault that i didn't point out that slug, the rapper in question, is not actually 100% caucasian, a fact that i had researched and decided not to include in the review. though i can't find the exact information right now i recall that he has one black parent and one white parent. because of his appearance a lot of people are going to assume that he is a white rapper. BECAUSE HE LOOKS WHITE. the media is fabulous at pigeonholing artists like this. people are fabulous at pigeonholing other people like this. my understanding of hiphop pivots on neither race nor geography; what i was saying was if atmosphere were to blow up any larger than they are now, slug is in danger of everyone ELSE doing it. the eminem comparison was based on appearance, yes, but more so because their lyrics share a great number of the same topics. race is and always will be a "pivotal" subject in hip hop, and if nothing else this is proof that it's always gonna be incendiary.
so what is this kid missing? am i missing something? did i accidentally write the most derogatory review on the face of the planet and my dreams of being a female cameron crowe (at ten years older than he was when he started) shot before anyone knows who i am? does everything pivot on race? am i racist for not addressing slug's lineage?am i racist because of the eminem comparison? oh my god, what if someone hated my rufus wainwright review?
(sigh.)
have you ever tried to teach a cat to fetch? the results are hilarious.
soundtrack: tullycraft, "superboy & supergirl"
(end.)
p.s. anyone who cares to follow the hyperlink and has an answer to any of the last Paragraph Of Questions, any perspectives would be appreciated, even if you end up hating me.